Often because the addiction is doing something for them. It can bring relief from anxiety, painful thoughts, difficult memories or circumstances that feel impossible to change, even while it causes real harm. Understanding what the behaviour provides is often the key to understanding why it persists.
When we think about addiction, our attention naturally goes to the substance or behaviour itself. How much someone drinks, what they take, how often they gamble, and how difficult it would be to stop. These are important questions. There is, though, another question that deserves much more attention.
What is the person gaining from their addictive behaviour, and what might they be left with without it?
In my work, I am less interested in the substance alone than in the person behind it. What is happening in their life, their thoughts, their feelings and their body that makes the behaviour so appealing, so necessary, or so hard to give up? Very often, the behaviour is doing something for the person, even while it is causing considerable harm.
The behaviour is doing a job
Alcohol, drugs, gambling, gaming and other repetitive and compulsive behaviours can offer temporary relief from parts of life that have become hard to face. For one person, alcohol quietens persistent anxiety or a stream of unwanted thoughts. For another, drugs bring escape from loneliness or a sense of inadequacy. Gambling can offer excitement and distraction from an otherwise flat existence. Even excessive screen time can become a way of avoiding uncomfortable feelings.
The behaviours differ, but the purpose they serve is often strikingly similar. Each offers a form of respite, a way out, however brief, from something that has become hard to bear.
Most people caught in an addiction do not want to be there. They do not want the arguments, the debts, the damage to their health, the guilt, the shame or the toll on the people they love. Many genuinely wish they could stop, and still they continue.
This is not a failure to understand the consequences. Most people understand them only too well. It is that the relief comes now, and the cost comes later. In the moment, the promise of relief can outweigh everything a person knows. It is entirely possible to want to stop and feel unable to, both at the same time.
This way of thinking has a long history. The Harvard psychiatrist Edward Khantzian, who developed the self-medication hypothesis, observed that many people are drawn to substances because of painful emotional states, and argued that the more useful question is not why someone uses, but what the drug does for them (Khantzian, 1997). The research evidence for his hypothesis is mixed, and addiction always involves biological and social influences as well. Even so, as a way of understanding why a behaviour persists, I find it one of the most valuable questions we can ask.
What lies beneath the behaviour
When I try to understand an addictive behaviour, I look at four connected areas of a person’s experience.
Thoughts
Persistent worry, intrusive thoughts, painful memories, self-criticism, guilt or a sense of hopelessness. Difficulty switching off, relaxing or letting go of particular events.
Emotions
Anxiety, fear, sadness, anger, disgust, loneliness, frustration or emptiness, and feelings a person finds difficult to acknowledge or express.
The body
Tension, restlessness, fatigue or poor sleep, which can be hard to live with, particularly when their cause is not understood.
Life and circumstances
Relationship difficulties, pressure at work, money worries, isolation, conflict, or a sense of being trapped in circumstances that cannot easily change.
These areas feed one another. Thoughts shape feelings, feelings show up in the body, and all of them shape behaviour, while circumstances affect each in turn. Addictive behaviour rarely exists apart from the rest of a person’s life.
The problem with temporary relief
Addictive behaviours can be remarkably effective in the short term. Someone drinks and feels less anxious. Someone gambles and, for a while, forgets their difficulties. The relief teaches a lesson, consciously or not, that this works.
Over time a cycle forms. Discomfort appears, the pull towards the addictive behaviour follows, the discomfort eases, and the original difficulty remains. Next time, the behaviour is the more familiar option. Researchers describe this as negative reinforcement, and one influential model argues that escaping and avoiding negative feelings is the central motive in addictive drug use (Baker and colleagues, 2004).
There is a wider point here. The things people do to protect themselves from difficult experiences can prevent them from resolving those experiences. Psychologists call these safety behaviours. They bring short-term relief while stopping a person from discovering that the difficulty can be faced. In one well-known experiment, people with panic and agoraphobia who dropped their safety behaviours showed a greater fall in anxiety and catastrophic beliefs than those who kept them (Salkovskis and colleagues, 1999).
Someone who uses alcohol to escape uncomfortable feelings, thoughts or memories may never get the chance to understand where they come from, or what would need to change for those experiences to mean something different and affect them less. The relief is real. The underlying difficulty remains.
Sometimes the thing that makes us feel safer in the short term is precisely what prevents us from moving forward.
Less, not more
This is why I believe lasting change often comes less from adding new techniques than from letting go of the behaviours that keep a person from facing what needs to be faced. Replacing one form of escape with another is not progress. The aim is a life that no longer needs the escape.
That does not mean every coping strategy is harmful, or that anyone should put themselves in genuine danger. It means distinguishing between what actually resolves a difficulty and what only protects us from having to face it.
Understanding the person, not only the behaviour
Helping someone understand the risks, reduce immediate harm and change the behaviour itself all matter. But if a person is living with persistent anxiety, unresolved experiences or a sense of hopelessness, simply removing the behaviour can leave them face to face with everything it was holding back.
This is not an argument for delaying change, or against medical or specialist addiction care. It is an argument for paying attention to what lies beneath the behaviour as well. Part of my work is helping people see clearly what the behaviour is doing for them, and what needs to change in their life, alongside the care of their own doctor and mental health professional. Sometimes simply saying out loud something that has gone unspoken for years is an important start.
What this means for families
It is entirely understandable to feel frustrated, frightened or angry when someone you love keeps doing something that causes harm, and to ask why they cannot simply stop when the consequences are so obvious.
It can help to consider that the behaviour may be serving a purpose that is not visible from the outside. That does not mean excusing it, removing responsibility or tolerating behaviour that puts your own wellbeing or safety at risk. It means recognising that the addiction is only one part of a bigger picture, and becoming curious about what the person might be struggling to face.
Families also need to watch their own responses. In trying to protect someone they love, they can find themselves constantly reassuring, rescuing or removing the consequences of that person’s behaviour. These responses come from love, but they can keep the pattern going. Supporting someone to address their difficulties is different from helping them avoid those difficulties.
And families need support themselves. Living alongside someone else’s addiction is exhausting and confusing. Understanding the person behind the behaviour should never come at the cost of recognising what the family is going through.
Looking beyond what needs to stop
Meaningful change involves more than removing an unwanted behaviour. It involves understanding why the behaviour became important in the first place, and addressing what made it feel necessary. This is rarely quick or straightforward, and where there is physical dependence it needs proper medical care. But we should never lose sight of the person while concentrating on the behaviour.
Sometimes the most important starting point is not asking someone to give something up, or finding another way for them to tolerate an unhappy situation. It is helping them face what needs to be faced, resolve what can be resolved, and come to terms with what cannot be changed.
Perhaps the most important question is not simply what someone needs to stop doing, but what needs to change in their life so that they no longer feel they need to do it.
How I can help
If this is you. Welberry Private membership offers confidential, psychologically informed advice and a small private group for people whose drinking, gambling, stress or other difficulties are becoming costly. Every session is led by me personally.
If this is someone you love. The Welberry family programme provides guidance to partners, parents and relatives directly, in a small private group and in private family sessions. Your loved one never has to take part, and is not identified in the group.
Your first conversation is confidential and carries no obligation.
This article is general information, not advice for your individual situation. Welberry Private is not an emergency or crisis service; if anyone is at immediate risk, contact your local emergency services.
References
- Baker TB, Piper ME, McCarthy DE, Majeskie MR, Fiore MC (2004). Addiction motivation reformulated: an affective processing model of negative reinforcement. Psychological Review, 111(1), 33–51. doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.111.1.33
- Khantzian EJ (1997). The self-medication hypothesis of substance use disorders: a reconsideration and recent applications. Harvard Review of Psychiatry, 4(5), 231–244. PubMed
- Salkovskis PM, Clark DM, Hackmann A, Wells A, Gelder MG (1999). An experimental investigation of the role of safety-seeking behaviours in the maintenance of panic disorder with agoraphobia. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 37(6), 559–574. doi.org/10.1016/S0005-7967(98)00153-3
